Sunlight: consensus with the lights on — and its natural pairing with 1-minute blocks

Thinking on this some more, we ALREADY have a Starlight covenant. Because miners’ coinbase rewards are frozen for 100 blocks, at any time there are 99 blocks of coinbase rewards which are effectively a Starlight covenant like I am describing. At current coin emission & price, that is 99 x 3.125 = 309.375 BCH at a price of ~$209 means $64 659.375 of TVL.

Ok $65k that’s not a world changing amount of money, but it’s mining security we didn’t really appreciate we had. Especially since it’s not just 1 actor that has the whole pie, all the recently active & successful miners have a slice giving them incentive to stay in the game.

  • Now unfortunately coinbase is running down (in BCH) terms, so that Starlight reward will by default decline.
  • Fortunately, price increases can happen at any time, and >2x 4-year price appreciation offsets the decline (excluding fiat inflation). This is the security budget contention that BTC guys rely on and everyone already understands.
  • Incredibly, transaction fees are wired into the coinbase payout (accidental genius by Satoshi??), so they not only replace the security budget but they also contribute to the Starlight bounty.

On Bitcoin BLAKE2B, in their quest to fight the evil mining cartels (somewhat valid, but not really) they first changed their algorithm, and then immediately after extended their CBM (Coinbase maturity period).

CBM extension: 45 days (6,480 blocks), temporarily for rewards mined in blocks 973,440–979,918/920; it was later extended further to ~180 days (25,920 blocks) for rewards from block 979,919 onward.

Their reasoning was to drive away miners that “didn’t have the best interests of the chain at heart”, but what they were doing inadvertantly was driving UP their Starlight bounty (in BTC-BLAKE2B terms). The miners’ lack of political involvement or control in the fledgling project meant their interests in having a short CBM were overruled.

This is an idea that perhaps BCH could consider. Of course miners won’t like having their payouts delayed, but perhaps it could be made appealing somehow, and maybe some miners would see it as more important (or not important) than others. Worth investigating.

Just to give a quick (and deliberately quite extreme) example. If we did the same as BLAKE2B & raised the CBM to 180 days (25 920 blocks), then the maths of our example above becomes 25 920 x 3.125 = 81 000 BCH at a price of ~$209 means $16 929 000 of TVL . Yes, that’s right, $17 MILLION of extra security - without needing a single extra hash, transaction fee or price increase.

One further point - the coinbase frozen funds in the “Starlight bounty” are sort of only half-value. Covenant locked Starlight bounties would be at a 2x effective multiple - because unlike the coinbase reward/fees they are slashed from the bad actors as well as rewarded (“for free”, or rather without PoW) to the good actors as described above. So it’s 2 BCH worth of security for every 1 BCH staked.

Between raising the CBM period & introducing Starlight covenant staking, BCH could potentially significantly increase its miner-incentivised security without needing any extra hashrate or price increases. Price increases (or increased transaction fee volume/revenue) would multiply security on top of that.

1 Like

In discussion with @bitcoincashautist, I have made three further breakthroughs:

  1. As well as the Starlight we have pre-existing in frozen coinbase payouts, we also have “phantom” (or off-chain) Starlight in the form of mining company legal contracts. Miners already make multi-month and even multi-year deals with energy companies locking in the price of electricity, with their warehousing & suppliers for their infrastructure costs & they sell their future mined coins at a fixed price via futures contracts because they’re in the business of mining not in the business of speculating on Bitcoin.

I don’t know a ton about that, but I do know it goes on and is a big deal in the BTC mining industry. Needs further investigation.

  1. Because of 1., miners may not be as averse to increasing the CBM as might be expected. Since from their point of view, they’re already betting on the chain continuing to exist for X months by their legal contracts, whether or not that’s also enforce cryptographically is possibly of little concern to them.

  2. The largest BCH app by TVL is BCH Bull. What do they do? Facilitate contracts between people who want to hedge their BCH & people willing to take the risk. The miners are the hedge side. This is surely a business opportunity for GP, but further it might actually be viable as an on-chain protocol. Perhaps it is possible to make an AnyHedge-style contract which allows anyone to leverage their BCH trustlessly against the miners’ future coinbase rewards (which the miners already hedge currently with legal contracts, but perhaps we could capture that value as on-chain contracts instead, which gives a KYC free market to on-chain speculators, drives transaction volume & TVL plus the Starlight benefit of entrenching miners’ future incentive to keep the chain running).

1 Like

All this sounds really good. One thing to think about is taxes and legal (like kyc) regulations that might come into play when hedging against fiat.

So if miners want to just be stone cold anonymous miners, the lock up period shouldn’t be so long that they have to do financial things to stay competitive.

Also, we would have an additional oracle risk. If miners are the root of trust themselves, we don’t want another dependency that could rug that root of trust like an oracle.

2 Likes