10-Minute Blocks Already Scale Globally—Will 1-Minute Blocks Push BCH into the Hands of Centralized Oligarchs?

Changing BCH’s block time from 10 minutes to 1 minute is extremely risky.

Look at history: BTC was reduced from 32MB down to 1MB because attackers launched DoS attacks and manipulated Satoshi Nakamoto into making that change. Infiltrators were already steering things from the inside back then, and they later hijacked BTC completely. Today, BTC can only return to 32MB through a hard fork—it has already been turned into digital trash, and their sabotage succeeded.

They cannot destroy BCH from the outside, yet they know how powerful BCH is, so they are constantly trying to undermine it from the inside through code changes. If you make just one fatal mistake, it is completely over, and BCH will become the second BTC.

Right now, BCH is already capable of serving as a global everyday currency. If we switch to 1-minute blocks:

  1. Will it still be able to sustain everyday spending for all of humanity?
  2. Will mining hash power inevitably have to rely on even more centralized oligarchs to survive?

Please reconsider carefully—there may be bad actors hiding within the community.

1 Like

Have you actually read the CHIP?

  1. Yes. Addressed in the CHIP. Although the scope of your question is pretty wild.
  2. No. Addressed in the CHIP.
1 Like

Yes. TPS floor stays the same, 32 MB x 1 10-min block == 3.2 MB x 10 1-min blocks.
If our blocks get full-ish, ABLA will automatically adjust to meet new demand just the same, capped at ~2x/year just the same.

No. Orphan rate stays in 0.5-1% range, and the one-time jump (from current ~0.05%) with 1-min blocks is latency-driven, not bandwidth driven. So if bandwidth keeps growing at same or greater rate than usage, we stay <2% even at 1k or 10k TPS. If you dreamed of 1GB 10-min blocks (4k TPS), same can be achieved with 100MB 1-min blocks.

And interestingly, the only somewhat negative effect of faster blocks is the orphan rate. All other scalability issues become easier: think node memory requirements. What’s easier? To keep 100MB in RAM while you validate a new block or 1GB in RAM? It’s generally easier to deal with a data stream in smaller but more frequent chunks. In the past we did scalenet experiments with 256MB x 10min blocks. I hope we will do the same kind of experiments with 25.6MB x 1min blocks, which would demonstrate this positive effect.

Also, smaller pools get more frequent payouts. With 10-min blocks a 0.1% pool could only hope to get one block once in a week. With 1-min blocks they can hope for a block every day. The payout variance smooths out.

1 Like

The prospect of eventually having 25.6 MB or 100 MB blocks every minute sounds great.

I would like to see the results of an experiment with 25.6 MB blocks x 1 minute compared to 256 MB x 10 minutes. It also makes sense that handling data in a fragmented way would be easier. I think BCH is scaling consistently, and it’s clear that 1-minute blocks is no obstacle to massive scaling.

Scaling is a journey, and we’re on the right track.

2 Likes